Every once in a while, a committee asks about having a Cry Room in their church. Having raised four children with my wife and taken them to church every Sunday, I am well aware of such rooms – though we hardly ever used them. We tried them once or twice but it was so obvious that no one in the room (children or parents) was interested in participating in the liturgy that we stopped using them. We found that taking them out in the Narthex for a few minutes seemed to be a better option.
When the topic of a Cry Room does come up, I typically suggest to the committee that the better way to handle it is to create a large enough Narthex or Gathering Space so that parents can take their children out into the space to give them a break. We usually suggest that some seating be provided there as well, with views of the liturgy and speakers in the room so that the parent care still hear the liturgy. In the 20+ years that we have been designing and renovating churches, we have never heard the comment “If only we had included a Cry Room…” It seems that other options are just better.
Below is an article from The Evangelist, a newspaper of the Albany, NY Diocese. It offers additional points of view on this topic. See what you think…
|To cry room or not to cry room|
BY ANGELA CAVE
Fifty feet from the worship space at Our Lady of Grace Church in Ballston Lake sits a cheery nursery room. If babies and children can’t stop crying or chattering during Mass, parents can hustle them to the carpeted room, which contains a changing table, books, toys and a speaker system.
“It’s kind of nice to have a place to go so you don’t have to walk a small child around,” said Alison Norton, a parishioner and the mother of a four-year-old and a two-month-old. Still, she and her husband “really only try to use it as a last resort.”
Eileen Stone, the mother of a seven-year-old and a three-year-old, agreed that the room is “convenient if you’re there and want to get back for communion,” but said she and others do not abuse the privilege.
Whether parents use the nursery room “really depends on what’s going on,” Mrs. Stone explained. “I think parents in general are trying to stay in Mass.”
Across the Albany Diocese, parishes offer a variety of accommodations for families: nursery rooms, couches in foyers, rocking chairs in the worship space or the Liturgy of the Word for children, during which children go to a separate room to hear the Scripture readings explained.
Room of requirement?
This is true around the country, as well. Cry rooms sprang up in churches after the Second Vatican Council in the late 1960s, but were often repurposed over the decades since then.
“People have become more accepting of the presence of children in congregations,” said Elizabeth Simcoe, diocesan chancellor for pastoral services, adding that the increase in movement and music during the liturgy since Vatican II more effectively engages children.
Some parish leaders told The Evangelist they oppose the concept of cry rooms, saying the separate spaces ostracize families and fail to demonstrate to children the realities of life in a parish community.
Traditional cry rooms remain in some parishes, but most parish leaders who spoke with The Evangelist agreed that the rooms should be a temporary solution when children can’t be soothed.
“We prefer people to be in the congregation. That’s the best,” said Rev. Dennis Murphy, pastor of Our Lady of Hope parish in Fort Plain.
However, parishioners there recently converted closets into a “gathering room” equipped with speakers and an altar-facing window. They use it for faith formation classes, daily Mass in the winter and as a family room if necessary during weekend Masses.
“It gives [parents] the freedom if they feel they need it,” Father Murphy said. “Some people won’t come [to Mass] because they’re afraid they’re distracting other people. Before we had [the room], people were just getting up and walking outside.”
We like them
During church renovations to his parish in the 1990s, glass doors were installed in the foyer. Now, almost every weekend during Mass, up to five parents retreat there with their children.
At St. John the Baptist parish in Walton, a cry room with pews and kneelers has accommodated up to a dozen families every weekend since 1964, said Henry Tassitano, a long-time usher.
He said he supports it because children can act disorderly during Mass.
“When the kids are jumping around and screaming, the parents pick them up and bring them in there, and then it’s calm,” Mr. Tassitano said. The children are “isolated, and I think they like that. They can hear [the Mass] in that room. The parents are still teaching them. They stand and kneel – they go through the whole routine.”
Corpus Christi Church in Round Lake takes a different approach: Four rocking chairs are scattered throughout the worship space for use by parents with small children and adults with physical limitations.
“They can sit [children] in the rocking chair and they can go to sleep like they do at Grandma’s house,” said Rev. James Clark, pastor.
Cry rooms should not be idealized, he said: “I don’t really see any reason for one because [parents] can also lose control and it can turn into a playroom. There are probably better pastoral ways to make both the parent and the children feel comfortable.”
Leaders at other parishes said that priests can preach over the noise of a crying baby and that a foyer with a changing table should be sufficient.
Rev. Richard Vosko, a Sunday presider at St. Vincent’s and a liturgical designer since 1970, has never installed a cry room in any of the 120 church buildings he has designed.
“It’s no way to treat a child and it’s no way to treat an adult with a child,” Father Vosko said. He advises providing nurseries where infants can sleep, toddlers can nap and play and older children can participate in the Liturgy of the Word.
“We can take a lesson from evangelical churches,” he remarked, describing rooms in those worship spaces with television monitors designed for nursing mothers and children with developmental disabilities.
“If there’s a perception that cry rooms are on their way out,” the priest-consultant added, “I’m happy.”